Pilgrim Turkey Sandwich

November 29, 2024

Pilgrim Turkey Sandwich

What’s more perfect the day after Thanksgiving than this Stonewall Kitchen recipe for a Pilgrim Sandwich!  Stop in today to grab a jar of your cranberry pepper jelly and enjoy all weekend long!

Instructions

Ingredients

  •  1/2 cup mayonnaise 
  • 16 slices whole grain bread
  • 2 cups prepared stuffing
  • 1 1/2-2 lbs. turkey, sliced
  • 1 jar Hot Pepper Cranberry Jelly 
  1. Spread Farmhouse Mayo on 8 slices of bread.
  2. Layer stuffi ng and turkey slices over mayo for each sandwich.
  3. Top with Cranberry Horseradish Sauce, New England Cranberry Relish or Hot Pepper Cranberry Jelly, another slice of bread, cut in half and serve.





Leave a comment


Also in Welcome to the Table

Fantasy Football Night
Fantasy Football Night

September 02, 2026

From Friday night lights to NFL Sundays, football is our family holiday. Get our favorite tailgate menu + shop football serveware and Stonewall Kitchen picks!

View full article →

Bluegrass BBQ Menu and Recipes
Bluegrass BBQ Menu and Recipes

June 13, 2026

View full article →

Sea Shores Dinner Menu & Recipes
Sea Shores Dinner Menu & Recipes

June 05, 2026

A beautifully set coastal table is the first course of any dinner party. It tells your guests they are somewhere special — that someone took the time, that this evening was made just for them. Our Sea Shores collection was designed exactly for this kind of moment: layered, serene, and full of the kind of coastal beauty that feels effortless and collected all at once.

View full article →